U.S. Court sides with ATA in port rules lawsuit
WASHINGTON -- The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ruled in favor of the American Trucking Associations late last week in its lawsuit seeking an injunction against the Ports of Los Angeles and Long Beach Concession Plans.
The three-judge panel ruled unanimously to remand the case to the U.S. District Court and indicated that the judge should grant the ATA an injunction against all or part of the Concession Plans, which among other things, require drayage carriers to use only company drivers with newer equipment.
"That requirement is dead," said Curtis Whalen, executive director of the Intermodal Motor Carrier Conference of the ATA.
"In short, motor carriers should not be required to adhere to the various unconstitutional provisions in the Ports' (concession) agreements, and are likely to suffer irrevocably if forced to do that or give up their businesses," the court stated.
ATA had not challenged the ports' Clean Truck Program, which bans older trucks and uses a container fee to subsidize the purchase of newer, cleaner trucks.
"We are extremely pleased with the decision," says Robert Digges Jr., ATA Vice President and Chief Counsel. "The judges understood that most of the elements of the Plans are not about safety, but rather are a regulatory effort by the Ports to create what they believe would be a more efficient drayage system."
As of Oct. 1, 2008, any motor carrier out of compliance with a Port's Concession agreement had been barred from entering that Port, a situation that caused motor carriers to suffer both short and long-term capital losses and injuries to business goodwill, ATA alleged.
The Court of Appeals decision said it would not entertain any petition for rehearing, although the Ports could appeal to the Supreme Court.
"Our Clean Truck Program is reducing toxic port truck pollution at an accelerated pace, and today's ruling by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals does not challenge the truck ban schedule or truck fees that are helping us successfully battle this health crisis," said Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa in a statement "We are committed to fighting this case because our Clean Truck Program is the most sustainable plan for ensuring a clean, safe and secure trucking system for the long-haul at the Port of Los Angeles."
The Coalition for Clean and Safe Ports, a group of 40 public health environmental, community, labor and faith-based organizations, issued a statement expressing outrage at the decision, and anger at the ATA for fighting the plans. "This is more dirty tricks from a shameless industry that has bullied its way around our backyard for too long," said Alicia Carrera, a Long Beach mother of three asthmatic children, in the coalition's statement.